| Name | Term |
|---|---|
| Theodore "Todge" Sutkowski | 2025 - present |
| Craig Cless | 2021 - 2024 |
| Dennis Abernethy | 2016 - 2020 |
| Jeffrey Aster | 2012 - 2015 |
| Donald Blank | 2010 - 2012 |
| Steven Ranjo | 2003 - 2010 |
| Mark Chilutti | 2000 - 2003 |
| John Nawn | 1998 - 2000 |
| Timothy Cleary | 1997 - 1998 |
| Dave Fortunato | 1996 - 1996 |
| Robert Murset | 1996 - 1996 |
| Robert Kestler | 1994 - 1995 |
| Robert Murset | 1990 - 1993 |
| Frank Campisi Sr. | 1986 - 1989 |
| Arthur Pettit | 1980 - 1985 |
| Joseph Teat | 1979 - 1979 |
| C. Thomas Gibbons | 1978 - 1978 |
| Gene Lorandeau | 1977 - 1977 |
| Jack Humma | 1975 - 1976 |
| Kirk Thieroff | 1973 - 1974 |
| Dan Capondanno | 1972 - 1972 |
| Unknown | 1968 - 1971 |
| Raymond Palzer | 1967 - 1967 |
| James T. “Doc” Weston | 1964 - 1967 |
| Herbert Hertz | 1963 - 1964 |
| Martin Leicht | 1956 - 1962 |